Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I suspect Every Door will become one of the top 3 editors for OSM in the near future.

I've been using it a lot since State of the Map 2022 for data capture. There are some many low hanging fruit to capture that its really efficient to improve coverage with minimal effort.

It does of course help to know the data model and tag guidance well for the amenities / data you are capturing. But there are opportunities for novice mappers too.




It helps that Every Door builds on the presets of iD, which are localized well and can often easily be found with searching, even by novice users. For me it has replaced OSM Go! as the app of choice for quickly adding details or changing a few things when outside.

For very novice mappers that don't want/need to add new elements, StreetComplete is probably still the best way to start out, at least if you're on Android.


I am in a walkabout through the Balkans and Central Europe. I’ve been using Maps.Me, which is great. I would love to contribute places and corrections.

Do you think Every Door is a good way to do that? Is this [1] wiki the right place to look for the data model/tag guidance you are talking about?

1- https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Beginners%27_guide


> I’ve been using Maps.Me, which is great.

I heavily suggest to switch to https://organicmaps.app/, which is a maintained fork of Maps.me, without user tracking and the whole wallet shenanigans.


More specifically, here's how to enter a bench into OSM: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity%3Dbench

You can just enter an amenity:bench poi, but it's useful to include additional information in tags. StreetComplete, for example, has a quest that adds the backrest information.

Osmand lets you add pois, but offers little guidance which tags are appropriate for which kind of poi. Every door seems a bit more helpful in that regard.


EverDoor uses https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema to facilitate mapping, meaning some suitable tags to the main tag are automatically suggested.


I'm glad there are people in this world concerned with tagging not just benches but also their backrest information.


I should add that when you add or edit a bench in Every Door, it shows the backrest and the material attributes at the top. So hundreds of benches in my area have these mapped :)


Absolutely! I agree with another user that you should switch to Organic Maps, but if you want to do more mapping, Every Door helps with that. It uses iD editor presets, so you can contribute even without knowing OSM tagging, although that would help.




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: