Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> I don't paint for you. I paint for myself. It's part of my life. A place where there are no compromises, no demands, no expectations, no projections, no assessments, no tasks, no metrics, no applause and no glory.

That sounds idealistic to the point of foolishness. The end result of your decision to quit art was that you had to get a job as a graphic designer. Doesn't that achieve even less of your vision?

A lot of people encounter this same dilemma: "do I want to conform to an imperfect system in order to stay in my chosen profession, or should I quit?"

By choosing to quit, you are giving up all of your leverage. You will be replaced by the next "yes man" who doesn't share your vision. If you stick with it, you can continue to nudge the system in the direction you want.



What’s all this about systems and leverage and wrangling external things to one’s own will?

It sounds like they just want to paint what they want, the way they want, and now do exactly that.

All this other stuff sounds like projection of your own concerns, and in pretty unfriendly language to boot.



There is nothing in the laws of nature that require "rational actor" application of leverage. Money does not buy happiness. It seems their previous job directly conflicted with their stated goal of expressing themselves, and the new graphic design gig does not. To me that achieved quite a lot.


Correct. Creating design and products serves others. Painting is personal. In my view, this is the difference between art and design. When creating art, I share my personal vision and emotions. Design is 'function over form', the goal of design is the UX and achieving a set of goals. The successful design/product is free from the designer's and creators egos, its purpose is to serve. You can use artistic tools and interpretation in graphic design as a medium, but you must deliver a balanced result within a set of rules and goals.


I just don't think there is much of a market willing to patronize any one person's self-expression without any demands.


Not just that. You spend way more of the 80000 hours in deliberate practice.


Practice towards what goal? To be the next Banksy? To be a millionaire? In my experience, practice has a limit. After a lot of hours I can code decently, and my stuff is working, but one of my developers which is in his twenties can outperform me with quality and elegance.

When you have a talent and a habit/routine, you can keep your form for years.

It is like muscle training, every day simple routine is more effective than two days in a week in the gym.

And my goal is to stay in shape and create something meaningful for myself, not to win the Art Olympics:)


unless you conclude that art and the “system” are incompatible on some fundamental way. i’ve arrived at a similar place as OP anyway




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: