Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is one of the funniest things I've seen in a long time. The company that has had 47 different messaging apps and changes them weekly trying to lecture the company that nailed it first time. Grow up Google.



But isn't the request for a cross platform standard? Sure Apple got their own internal standard right, but the experience across platforms still matters.


Doesn't matter to me, I have an iPhone. But regardless of personal experience, Google has tried and failed endlessly to make a not-shit messaging app for Android, and has now seemingly given up and adopted a terrible protocol, and is crowing about it like they're the saviour of messaging. They're not, they've just given up trying.


> "Google has tried and failed endlessly to make a not-shit messaging app for Android" …

Sadly, some would say that they've tried and succeeded multiple times to make a "not-shit messaging app for Android" and then promptly murdered each success just as it became popular.

> … "and has now seemingly given up and adopted a terrible protocol, and is crowing about it like they're the saviour of messaging."

Yeah, this seems to be pretty much the "standard model" for most "tech giants" these days. :(

> … "They're not, they've just given up trying."

On so many levels beyond just messaging. :(


Exactly. They've positioned this as creating problems for iOS users; however, all of these items are frustrating for Android users, not the other way around.

They're preaching to the wrong choir.


I literally have no issues when texting with friends who use android. Maybe it's because I'm old.


This


Yeah it does and Google removing XMPP federation from Google talk should means

"What happens when they no longer stand to benefit the most?"

should probably come up.


Yeah, so many in this thread are acting ignorant to what is actually going on. Which is surprising considering the audience.

RCS is a new standard, Google doesn't own it people.


Absolutely.

Google can't act indignant that Apple isn't following their lead after they tried, and failed, repeatedly, to follow Apple's.

Google wanted a proprietary messaging service like iMessage for Android. They failed. They failed so many times they gave up and became champions of RCS, a standard the carriers were limping towards supporting.

Google pretending they're now champions of open standards and Apple is the big-bad meanie is ridiculous.


How did they nail it if it doesnt work well with 80% of phones?


It does.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: