Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

This is such a techbro opinion. You know Picasso mastered "typical" art before he engaged in the abstract forms, right? That's what makes him special.



I disagree and I think it’s a legitimate question. Are you impressed by the artist or the art they produced? How much can a piece of art stand on its own without the context of the artist and their journey, perspective, evolution?

https://www.artsy.net/article/artsy-editorial-duchamps-urina... is a fun read :)


> How much can a piece of art stand on its own without the context of the artist and their journey, perspective, evolution?

I was recently taught that some art is not meant to stand on its own, out of context in which it was created.


> Picasso mastered "typical" art before he engaged in the abstract forms, right? That's what makes him special.

So in a hypothetical future where memory of Picasso's 'typical art' mastery has been lost, that which makes Picasso special will also be lost?

> This is such a techbro opinion

Scoffing at Picasso and (particularly) Pollock seems very mainstream in the working classes (and has been for as long as that art has existed.) It's not a "tech" thing.


And? That would be like if Chris Lattner got bored of making compilers and languages so he started making bizarre ML-generated creations and everyone started worshiping it because "he previously mastered typical programming, so anything bizarre or abstract he churns out now is automatically special!"


Art and Engineering are not the same.


I thought we were not supposed to define art


No, I didn't know.

But why should I care about that when the "art piece" I'm seeing at the moment doesn't impress me?


IMO thinking Picasso is special is more "tech bro" than not. Specially crypto-bros. Every time I see someone defending art like this and its value, it reads exactly like people defending crypto.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: