Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

They're both written by the same people, econ professors that are helplessly out of their field.

They're assuming a lot of things here:

* Rain means children watch televsion, no rain means they do not. This is a harsh oversimplification of how parents work.

* Cable TV was correlated to increased autism diagnosis. But what else is correlated to Cable TV? Wealth. And what's correlated to wealth? Getting your kid diagnosed properly in the country where healthcare is not easily affordable maybe? If you think that's a stretch, well, the entire paper is argued on this sort of thin ice.

* Autism isn't generally considered to have "a trigger", but some circumstances like stress can make it more obvious how a someone with autism is different. Autism is one of these things that aren't objectively measured, but often are diagnosed as a result of how annoyed parents are.




> And what's correlated to wealth?

Delayed family starts.

And what's a well-established contributor to autism?

Paternal age at conception.


N=1, but I grew up without cable TV (only one movie on the weekend), and I'm autistic. very so as a little kid.

my parents were both mildly on the spectrum, I apparently got a double dose. hooray for assortative mating!


They don't assume that, they showed rain correlates with TV watching. Are you making assumptions about what their study does without reading the article that explains it?




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: