Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Is that wrong-ness the responsibility of the military, or that of our govt/"society" not bothering to offer anything else as capable?



It's the responsibility of the government and by extension, the military. I suppose you could blame society at-large because we elect our representatives, but the majority of Americans already support single-payer healthcare and free or reduced college tuition.

It's disturbing to me that it's normal to concentrate efforts on recruiting poor teenagers to fight wars. The focus on the poor also has the effect of disproportionately impacting minorities.

Even if you survive, over the past decade hundreds of thousands of veterans have ended up with PTSD and even then they're left to fight for proper treatment under the VA. The VA has been failing veterans for decades and in some cases causes additional harm, including using experimental and ineffective treatment for covid while under their care (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7276049/).


Americans may claim that they support healthcare or education reform in the abstract, but they don't actually vote that way. Most people aren't willing to voluntarily pay higher taxes or cut other programs in order to actually implement those policies.

I'd like the government to give me all sorts of stuff for free as long as someone else is paying.


We're all already paying for it through health insurance companies, who are siphoning off huge profits.

Unless you're living off-grid the government already gives you mountains of "free" stuff paid for by taxes! It's an enormously long list of utilities and services that contains everything from fire departments to food safety. Mostly things that shouldn't be profit centers.


Guess I'm unclear what policy you think the military could do. Not recruit?


Specifically abandon recruiting methods that target the poor would be a start.


unless you know recruiters personally and have more than an anecdotal example or policy to share, that specific targeting, especially in terms of a policy, doesn't happen but yes recruiters will go to the high schools in poor areas.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: