Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

[flagged]



> I believe I am no mad preacher, and have more authority to speak on this matter than most of Western "geopolitical think tanks"

> I studied politics, sociology, military sciences, and history as my passion

> Do not do "Mad preacher" labelling

I cannot test your knowledge. For me you are just another account crying large-scale war. You present no evidence, other than a few observations, stories and a strong conviction of self-grandeur.

I'm not saying you are lying, being super intelligent or just exaggerating, but many people won't "just trust you". You should understand that.


The author would be more credible if they revealed their identity and showed some credentials, otherwise it's just another voice on the internet; it could be a subject matter expert, it could be an armchair expert, could be part of the Russian propaganda machine, or it could be a troll.


> I'm not saying you are lying, being super intelligent or just exaggerating, but many people won't "just trust you". You should understand that.

I don't ask you to trust me. I ask HN readers to listen to their own countries' military experts.

Your generals who spent half their life studying Russian, and Chinese militaries in Westpoint, Saint-Cur and Sandhurst didn't do that for nothing.


If Putin attempts war against a NATO country, e.g. Lithuania, my only hope is that NATO will stand together and respond with forces on the ground. If he escalates to use nuclear weapons, he's a fool and I hope the Russian people will tear him to pieces in the street before he condemns them to death.


> If he escalates to use nuclear weapons, he's a fool

And we're all be dead. Nukes is basically flipping the board; if I can't win, nobody will.

I mean I hope that won't happen, and that Russia's military collapses in on itself as Russia's access to the international (financial) market is pulled. That'll probably take a while though, it's attrition. It might make the Russian people upset enough to be able to enact change, but not while the police and military are still on Putin's side and happy to stop any protests or whatnot.


Yes, one thing about Putin's mafia form of government is that if the godfather is no longer able to keep the money flowing, he will be put to pasture and someone with a cooler head will take his place. It's an unfortunate situation for Russia but even if Putin goes insane and wants to die in a nuclear fire, his system of patronage will follow the logic of greed. And they're going to be very angry about this when they lose their yachts.


It is going to be very interesting to see if there is in fact a military alliance behind the military alliance.


I had doubt before this.

I mean, everyone in Europe had doubt that anyone would respond to Hitler before he invaded Poland.

But when he invaded Poland, the world changed on a dime. I don't think there will be any daylight between any western nations now, when it comes to how to deal with Russia. You can't deal with a mad dog by giving it treats.

If there was any doubt before about NATO's mutual obligations, Putin has done away with that. Russia is about to become North Korea until one of Putin's close friends kills him. Which should take about six months.


People are wary of government messaging because of things like the Gulf of Tonkin and the WMD debacle.

Unfortunately in this case, it was credible and the strategy of declassifying did seem to work but clearly Putin has made up his mind.

One more thing: this is definitely not the place for "I told you so".




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: