Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Homelessness expert here. This data set is garbage. HUD data only includes those in the federally mandated HMIS (Homeless Information Management System). This data excludes 1) people who don't access services; 2) people who access services from private, non-federally funded programs (like faith-based groups); and 3) typically undercounts those with SUD, mental-health issues, and especially people of color.

A recent BGC study estimates that, in Seattle, for example, HMIS data doesn't include up to 40% of people in encampments.

Garbage In -> Garbage Out. Pretty sweet effort, though. Wish the feds were smart like this.




Since the reports main premises is that the number of homeless hasn't changed, does it matter that the groups you mention are left out?

Is there reason to believe the groups that are under counted experienced a larger increase the the groups that were included?

It seems the data collection has been consistent, so the conclusion of the article seems correct.


Do you have a reference for that study? Also, what's your impression of how correlated this data is with the true numbers? Does a rise in the counts indicate the true numbers are also probably going up, or could it just be an artifact of more people being in the HMIC system or something?


The unsheltered count is a thing and does include people who don't access services.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: