Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I wonder what rate of adverse effects will be considered acceptable for a drug administered to people known to have the virus? For vaccines, our tolerance seems very low. I suspect we don’t actually think prevention is better than a cure.



It would depend greatly on their age, I would posit for that those over 65, any drug that killed less than 10% of the people who took it would be acceptable.

Vaccines are part of a broader political debate, the problem in politics is people are picking sides. It's very rare to run into a person who doesn't support the vaccine mandates but did get vaccinated. People are generally either anti-vax & anti-mandate, or vaccinated and pro-mandates.

The antivax crowd uses the same persuasion techniques to discourage vaccination that media uses to convince young people that COVID poses any risk of mortality to those under 17. That is to say one or two extremely rare outcomes are trumpeted loudly in order to convince society at large of the danger that is virtually non-existent.


I’ve taken the vaccine and am vehemently anti-mandate. I know others in the same position. I haven’t admitted my anti-mandate views to anyone in person who I am not close to and trust. You’re right though, people definitely pick sides. I get the feeling people could hardly comprehend someone having a “mixed” view like mine, but from my vantage point it’s quite simple: I chose to get vaccinated; I recommend it for most above a certain age; I don’t think blanket coercion is justified.


I think you will find many of the loudest voices on these matters in the media will have quietly gone in for their top up 3rd dose recently.


It's very rare to run into a person who doesn't support the vaccine mandates but did get vaccinated.

Or it's very rare for them to say so in the presence of fear mobs. Mixed opinions are far more common than their (in)visibility would suggest.


This matches my experience. Ive recently been more open about science-based (to the extent i can as a layperson) perspectives that dont fit neatly into the binary news representation(s), and discovered many more nuanced perspectives than the internet would have you beleive.


Good point. This does seem to be the predominant view of my friends but I had assumed heavy sampling bias.


I disagree.

I got the vaccine hoping it would make travelling easier and because I don't want to spend money on useless tests. Too bad I ended up having to get tested anyway.


> It's very rare to run into a person who doesn't support the vaccine mandates but did get vaccinated.

How do you tell?


From the maga hat




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: