Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

If all of my policy preferences code as progressive but I think Kendi and the white fragility lady are jackasses, what does that make me then under your definition?



Charitably, cognitively dissonant and more harshly, a useful idiot some would say. I’d assume an egalitarian person who means well and has started to become suspicious of the more illiberal aspects of progressive motivations.


Wow. So, what, I have to vote Trump now? That won't be happening but always interesting to hear different perspectives.


> So, what, I have to vote Trump now?

Why is that the implied option?


Americans live in a two party system. The only realistic alternative to the Democrats, who are associated with progressives, are the Republicans.


Even if you believe that a two party system is the only possibility, you can do many things that don’t involve voting for Trump.


The 'useful idiot' part that I replied to.


“Useful idiot” is a term coined back in the day to describe people who unwittingly spread the propaganda of communists without really understanding the ultimate goals. In this case being a progressive while disagreeing with the leading ideas of the movement.

And no it doesn’t mean a vote for Trump. It means not supporting candidates that parrot this type of rhetoric and to not support causes/movements that are a part of it. FWIW Trump did ban critical race theory from being brought into federal offices and Biden quickly reinstated it under the guise of “learning to be nice to each other” - which it isn’t. Biden, in this case, I believe is a useful idiot for propagating their propaganda, mistaking it for harmless “diversity training”. There’s a big difference!


Worth reflecting on how the John Birch Society looks in retrospect, now that you mention it.

Prophets, or paranoid fools? Are we looking back and saying, gosh, we should have listened to them, that damn Jane Fonda ruined America.


according to kendi's framework, you would be a racist.


Someone who is looking for another group. Kendi and DiAngelo’s ideas are what progressives are actually enacting.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: