Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

In what way(s) aren't PWAs as good, would you say?

Personally, I think >90% of all apps I've used could be implemented as a PWA, as nothing they do really require native performance.

The main issues I see are

1. The DX needs some improvement

2. Apple are dragging their feet implementing new web tech on Safari, and are therefore holding everyone hostage since you cannot install any other browser on iOS.




From my perspective (also iOS and macOS dev) PWAs can be great for a lot of use cases, especially if you just need a mobile offering for an existing SaaS product. If Apple actually implements some of the required features for PWAs in Safari they will still always be missing native controls, gestures, navigation will be off and I think the biggest difference is you'll be missing access to all the deeper integrations you can do with the OS through Apple's various frameworks and APIs. Whether or not thats important to your app varies a lot, for a lot of CRUD apps that need something in the stores the PWA approach with capacitor is likely fine.

For the record I'm also pro Apple implementing richer PWA support as I personally see both approaches coexisting.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: