Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>The USA created a democratic government in the hopes that the troops could be withdrawn and the local Afghan government would maintain its own affairs and keep terrorists from operating in its country

Lemme stop you right there. Even the idea of "voting" was foreign to them. You have to understand, we can provide security, but if they think democracy is stupid what do we do? Tell them democracy isn't stupid?

>There are many Americans that care that after 20 years the Taliban will take over again shortly after the troops are gone.

Yeah, No. I mean, psychologically it's weird to see the place we were at for 11 months get overrun by Islamists but at some point we've just realized that Afghanistan is their country. If they want to run it that way, with an Islamist political party running the entire government then that's their right. The US should stay out of it.




"but if they want to run it that way, with an Islamist political party running the entire government then that's their right.

I agree to that, but it is really not that simple.

There are many more foreign nations and groups involved in Afghanistan than just the US.

The Taliban are very alien to many afghan people, too and considered a foreign force.

The solution?

No simple one that I can see.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: