Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Self-publishing has always been an option for authors. Some publishing houses offer you resources to publish your work. You simply pay them and they review and print your book. It seems to be a fair arrangement. However, after five minutes in Google, you will find out that many self-published authors had terrible experiences or were scammed. Finding a decent and professional publishing house requires time. You cannot trust the first one you find in Google.

Those "self-publishing companies" are often next-generation vanity press. Then again, bottom tier traditional publishing— and the dangerous part is, this includes bottom-tier deals from "Big 5" imprints— are basically vanity press as well.

The number of first-time authors who get traditional deals actually worth taking (the kind that come with 6-figure marketing budgets and TV spots delivered in-hand) is probably in the double digits per year— it's not that hard to "get an agent" if you're willing to take abuse, but 98% of literary agents have no real connections but serve as an HR wall, existing solely to filter out the deserving perma-slush, that will probably be replaced with machine learning algorithms soon.

Publishing gives writers a possibly necessary but very unpleasant introduction to the reality of commerce— there are so, so many people out there looking to get as much as they can (money) and give as little as possible. This applies when you pay thousands of dollars to a "self-publishing company" and get work (cover design, editing, et al) that a high schooler could have done... but it also applies when you sign away your rights to a "Big 5" for a piddly advance and no marketing.

I think the game's very different for programming books than it is for, say, fiction. Generally, people don't write books about Python because they think they're going to quit their day jobs. At the same time, people who can write even passable programming books are fairly few in number... whereas people who can write passable novels that could in theory become the next 50 Shades are commonplace (although people who can write good novels are very rare).

It's impossible to say what it requires not to get scammed in publishing— you have to take some risks, and who can say what risks are right to take?— but a good first step is to accept the very real possibility that you do everything right and still don't sell more than a few dozen copies. Sometimes terrible books sell (50 Shades) and sometimes great books go ignored for thirty years.




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: