Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It always intrigued me: why is it somebody else's job to secure a company's website? This is completely backwards. Rather than investing into security, they let somebody else fix the problems while leaving their users exposed. At this point, it is more ethical to sell whatever vulnerabilities you find to the black market than to "ethically" disclose them.



>why is it somebody else's job to secure a company's website?

Some people find bug bounties to be lucrative, especially in low cost of living countries. Other people find them fun. Other people find they look good on resumes. But no one is required to participate in them. If you don't want to spend your time looking for vulnerabilities in other people's software, don't do it.

>Rather than investing into security

Running a bounty program costs money, both to pay the participants as well as to pay employees to investigate the reports (most of which are junk). Also it's not a one or the other. You can run your own internal red team while also running a bug bounty program.

>they let somebody else fix the problems while leaving their users exposed

It's usually not the bug bounty participants who fix the problem. Usually the bug bounty participant reports the problem, then the company fixes it.

>At this point, it is more ethical to sell whatever vulnerabilities you find to the black market than to "ethically" disclose them.

Why is it more ethical to sell them on the black market? The black market is composed of people who actively want to harm others for their own benefit. Seeking them out and selling them tools specifically for that purpose is unethical. I don't see what's ethically wrong with reporting a vulnerability to a company through its bug bounty program.

There are of course other options besides those 2. Full disclosure for example.

Also you could sell it on the grey market to people who promise to only use it for legal purposes (e.g. for governments to legally hack people). https://zerodium.com/




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: