Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The ability to carry road-trip quantities of antimatter in a briefcase would take the threat of terrorism to a whole new level. How much would you need to take out a plane? A building? A city?

Nuclear cars would be cool, too, but I think we need to consider the weaponizable nature (both for governmental military forces and for terrorists) of these technologies.




From Wikipedia: The reaction of 1 kg of antimatter with 1 kg of matter would produce [...] the rough equivalent of 43 megatons of TNT. For comparison, Tsar Bomb, the largest nuclear weapon ever detonated, reacted an estimated yield of 50 megatons.

I dare say this would take a briefcase bomb to a whole new level.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antimatter#Fuel


There's no way to contain it without big, heavy equipment.


The energy density of antimatter has 9 more zero compared to TNT.

So, roughly speaking, a soda bottle of antimatter is a megaton of TNT[1]. Well, half a soda bottle if you ask the stewardess for a soda of non-antimatter once you get on the plane.

If you want to equal the largest of nuclear warheads tested, you will have to pay a small overage fee on your luggage.

[1] I'm ignoring containment overhead. Once you show me a gram of antimatter we can talk about containment.


There will be a scanner on the airport line that would detect antimatter atoms in quantities of more than a few thousand atoms, which is what you would need to create an explosion.

So the problem is making it safe enough to not explode even if the electric-antimatter converter is shot, crushed, disintegrated in an explosion or superheated.

Bond the anti hydrogen with anti Oxygen, Bond it with an anti-matter noble gas (elements that refuse to react). Maybe there is a creative way to make it hard to unlock into it's explosive state. That way you can only dole out the energy with a complex process that an accident would not recreate.


Antimatter will annihilate when it comes into contact with any normal matter; it's not a chemical reaction. You can't make antimatter 'inert' because it's reactivity doesn't depend upon some chemical property (arrangement of anti-electrons for example), but simply on the fact that it's antimatter. Hence the use of magnetic fields for containment since they prevent contact with ordinary matter.

Your airport scanner would thus have to infer the presence of antimatter rather than detecting it directly (by looking for high-energy photons), but if your containment vessel is leaking then you have bigger problems than law enforcement :-)


No there will not be a scanner because it's impossible to tell the difference from afar.

Scientists would LOVE to find a difference, it would explain so much about the universe.

And no, there is no "creative way to make it hard to unlock into it's [sic] explosive state". Such a thing is impossible. The only thing you can do is make some kind of really good containment.

And BTW a few thousand atoms is not much, even for anti-matter. It's about the energy of a flying mosquito.


> There will be a scanner on the airport line that would detect antimatter atoms in quantities of more than a few thousand atoms, which is what you would need to create an explosion.

If I've got a kilo of antimatter in a briefcase, I'm just going to set it off at the scanner then, killing the ~10k people in the airport... and half the city it's part of.


Half the city? That much antimatter would take out half a state.

1Kg of antimatter is about the energy of the Tsar Bomba if you want to try it out: http://www.carloslabs.com/node/16


What threat of terrorism? When's the last time you were terrorized? There is no terrorism except in the media and in ourselves.

Surely as scientists we could take some comfort in the statistics of the likelihood of any one of us actually experiencing "terrorism" first hand....


Widen your scope beyond just the US.


I can already buy an unlimited amount of gasoline from thousands of sources..

I can also buy any type of "missle" (read vehicle).

I can also buy fertilizer, cheaply.

Say I forego the fertilizer route, and fill my car full of gasoline. Now, all I need to is then put a rag in the gas intake and break off the tab. I have a molotov cartail, that, when steered does a lot of damage.

It's easy to kill people and cause terror. Moreso, if you are an engineer. But its decency and ethics that keep people from doing these sort of things.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: