Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Doesn't Apple generally make worse cables than the competition?

It is very rare for a PC laptop power cable to break. There's a rubber grommet which protects the cable as it enters the plug from extreme and repeated bending.

For supposed aesthetics, Apple don't include this, and their cables fray easily.

(This is based on my experience managing hardware for a small organization, <50 staff. After about 5 years, Apple laptops come back with damage to the shiny screen from rubbing against the keyboard, and usually a wrecked power supply cable. Sometimes we have to replace the PSU within the 5 years. The rest of the laptop is usually in good condition, i.e. the case, keyboard, ports.

Dell/HP/Lenovo/etc business laptops come back with the cables in good condition, the matt screens suffer less even with similar keyboard marks, but the cases usually look a bit scruffy. Depending on usage, we might have replaced the battery after ~3 years, which is either easily done by the user, or takes 5 minutes with a normal screwdriver to remove the back case.)




I've never seen cables as bad as Apple's. I have multiple Apple cables that I've patched up with electrical tape, and I'm quite careful to avoid kinking them.


Apple's cables are bad. Never been a problem for me because I take care of them, but people shouldn't have to be as careful as I am.


Very rare? Come on. I still have that Dell somewhere which had cable frayed right where its stress relief mold ended.


"rare" != "unique"

I have a stack of old laptops 2 feet high, and my old Dell that frayed at the strain relief is the only one whose cable crapped out.


> It is very rare for a PC laptop power cable to break.

The failure was usually the plug breaking loose from the board. (Both on PC laptops and old Powerbooks with the barrel plug.)




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: