Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> The observed universe is mostly gas, rock, nuclear reactors we call stars, and so on. Where are the proofs that it has a "purpose" or "meaning"?

Where are the visible proofs of love? Of mathematical formulas? Of radio waves? Where is the tangible visible obvious proof that the earth is not flat? Where is the tangible proof that your life has any future that makes any sense for you to get up in the morning and do any work?

"There is no meaning because I can't physically see an old guy in the sky" has to be one of the least developed arguments in this sphere...




>Where are the visible proofs of love?

Physiological changes in the body/brain consistently assosiated with said self-reported state.

>Of mathematical formulas?

We can reproduce most of their results with physical objects (adding 1 and 1 rocks makes 2 rocks, the shortest line between two points we can draw with less ink on a piece of paper is the straight line, in a sphere it's the geodesic and it indeed saves planes gas, and so on...)\

>Of radio waves?

Err, plenty of visible proofs of radio waves. You can very easily scan a room with a portable scanner, not to mention we hear the sound they carry.

>Where is the tangible visible obvious proof that the earth is not flat?

Photographs from space?

>Where is the tangible proof that your life has any future that makes any sense for you to get up in the morning and do any work?

There's none, since that doesn't exist.


> There's none, since that doesn't exist.

Ah, I see. Sorry about that. If you feel that way in your life, then it makes sense that you believe the things you write.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: