Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> a flat tax that affects everyone equally.

I think you mean "a sneaky way of implementing a regressive tax".

If you are spending 90% of your income on your day to day, inflation-sensitive expenses, versus 20% of your income, any positive inflation rate will have a greater effect on your margin of survival. Plug in 10% and 1% and see for yourself.




The tax system is not the place to try to solve poverty - you just end up over complicating it without even fixing the problem. Zero tax does not equate to zero poverty.

Let the tax system and social services systems stand on their own. Don't conflate one with the other.


I tend to agree, but it's also crazy to suggest that inflation affects society evenly.


70% of Americans have less than $1,000 in the bank.

Say there was 0% inflation for the last 50 years, how much do you think the number above would change?


The percentage would be lower, average savings higher. Because people's wages would have eroded less, and money not keeping it's value is incentive to live a consumptive lifestyle.... Bitcoiners hodl, for example, in spite of crashes and even with the risk it all goes to zero tomorrow.


Are you sure people would have saved the money versus buying a better car, house, electronics, etc..

Are you sure inflation is the reason people live a 'consumptive lifestyle'?

I'd argue it is 'cheap' access to debt - student loans, housing loans, credit cards, etc.. that has prevented people from saving.

Historically though the savings rate to today isn't much different than 60 years ago - around 10% in 1960 down to around 7% today.

Bitcoin is an asset/investment like any other, including the dollar, and all can go to zero under the right circumstances. That is why no single asset should be HODL'd in spite of others, diversify.


Cheap access to debt is inflation. You are violently agreeing with me.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: