Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Such a great text. However, the fact that the programmers are all "he" and the only reference to a female pronoun is a "hostess greeting her guests" was somewhat abrasive to me.

Previous discussion on the topic: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8036547

I get it -- it's written in an old style. And I don't want to censor art.

SO -- I made a "mod" for the book, that randomizes the pronouns each time. https://xtao.stream

Still a WIP -- want to add more info/motivation to the site before really releasing it, but I wanted to share here & would love any feedback.. expecting downvotes.. ;)




I love it! Instead of just complaining, you're also offering a solution.


Yeah! Another job well done by Minitruth!


Got em! In all fairness, I do agree with the sentiment behind your trolling though. That's why I made this a "mod" where the user provides the original text.

It's an interesting approach to the "relevancy update" without suppressing or censoring the original. I -really- don't want to be the person breaking penises off statues or changing the edit so Han shoots in defense.

This is not rewriting of truth. This is Counter-Strike vs. Half-Life. An original-source-available remix.


Build whatever you want, I just think the text being “abrasive” because of masculine pronouns is beyond goofy as fuck.


cool story bro, thx for clarifying your troll


Alternatively, you can just use singular 'they'. (Although I hate it, seems the easier option)


Definitely easier, but it would sacrifice a lot of the style IMO. I did hardcode the 'host greeting their guests' part.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: