Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Read the Republican-led Senate Intelligence Committee report.

https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/sites/default/files/docu...




I’ve read it. Like I said, total conspiracy theory. Nothing in there to suggest Trump was involved in anything, and we know now that the infamous Steele dossier was bogus.


> Nothing in there to suggest Trump was involved in anything

No. But so many members of his immediate circle are named as being involved.

> we know now that the infamous Steele dossier was bogus

This is a weird thing to say. The Steele dossier was presented as a set of unsubstantiated claims which required further investigation.

Disproving a limited number of them (eg, Michael Cohen doesn't seem to have been in Prague when one of the claims said he was) doesn't show much except that specific claim is unproven.

Additionally, many of the allegations have been proven!

Notably - and amusingly - the "pee tape" part of the dossier hasn't been disproved at all. Given the huge amount of attention that has gained one would think holes would have been found by now. The Mueller report actually adds some weight to this story, noting how a Russian associate of Cohen had claimed to have "stopped the flow of tapes" from the owners of the hotel Trump stayed in.

Read for yourself! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steele_dossier#Veracity_and_co...


That’s not how evidence works. The onus is not on Trump to prove a negative. And crucially:

”Rtskhiladze later admitted he had been told the tapes were fake, but he did not communicate that to Cohen, the report says.”

Literally a hoax.


> That’s not how evidence works. The onus is not on Trump to prove a negative

Of course. As I said - it was a set of unsubstantiated claims. Some turned out to be false, but some didn't. It wasn't a bogus dossier.

> Literally a hoax.

So you pull the one footnote from that which supports your viewpoint and ignore all the rest that doesn't?

The point wasn't if the tapes were fake: the point was if Trump believed they might exist.


yea, the silly thing is that we all really underestimated or at least accurately estimated the involvement of Russian actors in the rise of trump in 2016. This is cannon, and the report was written by republicans.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: