Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> “You’ll see the call to action is ‘Request Demo,'” Gellis said. “So, arguably, a user who sees this ad and clicks legitimately on it will be looking to get a demo of the analytics tool we were marketing.

This guy is deluded. People click random things to get more info, and they might not have liked the more info they got so didn’t go ahead with the demo.




I stopped reading the content of marketing websites ages ago, I just click on whatever is big and orange or other flashy colors until I see something that looks like a list of features, or whatever I'm looking for ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. I don't expect to be the only one to have this marketing blindness. I guess I'm a bot based on my behaviour?


If the landing page has a bunch of soft stuff like 'expands synergy' on it I am just going to assume I was not the target audience. I'm not a CEO, I'm a practitioner. Put something crunchy in there. Sorry you guys wasted your marketing budget on a mistargeted ad lmao.


> Sorry you guys wasted your marketing budget on a mistargeted ad lmao

Ad nauseam did exactly this until the extension was banned from chrome store: https://adnauseam.io/


If anybody is considering using this for privacy reasons don't.

If you want to piss off as dev or act like a bot, only then use it.


You can use it for privacy, by ruining the tracking data.


No it won't. Clicking on random ads doesn't increase privacy. It just changes what the advertiser thinks of your interests.

To load an ad, you have to allow trackers. If you allow a tracker, you might as well allow the ad instead of hiding it. AdNauseam just hides it.


> It just changes what the advertiser thinks of your interests.

How is this not increasing privacy? The point is to keep my real interests private from creepy marketing departments.


> The point is to keep my real interests private from creepy marketing departments.

Which is why you block all ads? Companies don't care about 'real interests'. They see the things you click on and show you more ads based on it. They earn money. That's it.

The marketing department knows the sites you visit because it has to serve the ad so this thing can click on it.

Use uBlock Origin.


It still does exactly this for me because it is not banned from the internet (yet).


Exactly, there's more than 1 factor while his campaign didn't work at all.

As mentioned in other comments, his ad spend was pretty low anyway, you can't come to conclusions if a campaign is successful from 11 clicks.

The main problem is that his creative/lander or his copy didn't convert.

Having the clicks differentiate from the ad source compared to your tracking tool is pretty common as well. If you're using just GA to track it, the numbers are going to be wildly different with people having Adblockers.

I've worked on some large B2B ad campaigns on LinkedIn, some of them we only ever got 1 lead, but that lead was worth a lot more than that the campaign budget, so that was a success for us.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: