Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

On the other hand, I also have a hard time trusting the government with the health data. I would actually prefer a federation of foundations under public law.



As for most things, we probably would be better of with a lot of separated institutions instead of a big centralized governement: one in charge of police, one in charge of health, on in charge of education, one in charge or budget, all of them separated and not governed by one entity at the top.

But that's what we got now, so If I have to chose, I chose the gouvernement. At least in my country: they are paying for health already.


> At least in my country: they are paying for health already.

Assuming that you pay taxes it will be you paying for health care services, albeit indirectly. If you live on government subsidies it is others who pay for your health services. The government is the intermediator between tax payers and beneficiaries.


Of course, I used that phrasing to highlight the fact it causes less conflicts of interests (albeit not none).


The most terrifying words in the English language are: I'm from the government and I'm here to health.


Yeah well, that's maybe an over active imagination. The best healthcare systems in the world (with respect to quality, and quantity of people getting it) are public health systems. So I dunno, I'd rather have the (functioning democratic) government, a body I actually have a stake in be in charge of health as opposed to a body that it's only duty is to it's share holders. As I see it, a governmental body is (should be) something we all have equal share in independent of our financial situation. I'm quite aware to the ways this body could malfunction. But at least we have a moral footing to work against these malfunctions. With a public/private company as long as it makes money, I have no moral grounds to oppose it ruining my and our lives.


In Europe the most terrifying words you can hear are "We're gonna switch to a US style health system."


US has best health care in the world.


Slight correction: the US has the world's best health care that money can buy.


I heard enough about the Amercan health system to be eternally grateful to the one I have in France.

I made my tax declaration this month.

I made it with a smile.


You will say that if you live in the US, try living in some other developed countries with free healthcare, you will change your mind.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: