Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Is letting Google, Facebook or Apple control every aspect of our lives by sending them all our personal data, contacts and network information voluntary more secure?

I would rather run every application in its own VM under a different unprivileged user

P.s. the browser is the main attack vector on mobile, not only because it's so complex that bugs are everywhere, but mostly because web app security sucks




> the browser is the main attack vector on mobile

Citation needed. Browser-based attacks are difficult to come by, because it's just easier to attack an application instead.


>Citation needed. Browser-based attacks are difficult to come by, because it's just easier to attack an application instead.

You require a citation then make an assertion with with no supporting source.


Browsers usually have fairly strong security models, since they are expected to constantly run untrusted code (which has nothing to do with web app security, FWIW). Apps rarely get this kind of scrutiny and often don't (Android) or can't (iOS) employ features that browsers can to do, such as multiple processes.


OS constantly execute untrusted code as well.

Many game engines do it as well, just think about DOOM mods

I think the point is that browsers are not as good as an OS as an application platform (given the limitations) but are as complex as an OS and have more bugs

The fact that mobile apps are terrible is not an excuse for having a terrible document protocol used for applications

Apple invented mobile apps as we know them today,but native apps in general have served people well for ages

We are at a point where a native app with some API is more maintainable than a browser app

Not even talking about the ecosystem and its fiascos, like npm corrupted libs used by millions without even looking at a single line of source code or the famous leftpad incident

It doesn't really matter where the weakness is, if it is exploitable

As Alan Kay once said "the web was made by amateurs at best"




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: