Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Even the case-less hard drive icon in the Quick Look preview window incorrectly uses an image of a spinning disk to represent an SSD.

Its called a symbol. What else would you do, put a piece of plastic called SSD instead?




Indeed it is a symbol. Does the author have the same objection about other icons? Let's talk about some of the icons in the System Preferences window (https://help.apple.com/assets/5DB8A4A0094622D56C6D1279/5DB8A...)

The Date & Time icon is an analog clock with a paper calendar icon on top of it. Does the author think this is "incorrect" because the computer does not actually have a tiny analog clock inside of it? It does have another type of clock based on a newer technology.

The Energy Saver icon is a light bulb with a standard base screw-in socket. The computer doesn't have one of those inside it either. And the computer's energy usage isn't primarily from lighting. But the icon is an LED bulb, and we understand those as a way of saving energy.

The Screen Time icon is an hourglass. Is this incorrect because the computer does not internally use an actual hourglass to judge whether your session is too long? Nevertheless, the idea comes across OK because you can use an hourglass for similar purposes.


> The Energy Saver icon is a light bulb with a standard base screw-in socket. The computer doesn't have one of those inside it either. And the computer's energy usage isn't primarily from lighting. But the icon is an LED bulb, and we understand those as a way of saving energy.

Interestingly, this used to be a normal lightbulb, then evolved into a CFL and is an LED bulb today.


OWC has custom icons for their SSD's

https://eshop.macsales.com/support/custom-drive-icons


At that point it's just a picture. I like the old symbols, even if they're antiquated now. Maybe when I remember the humble beginnings, using floppies, there's some nostalgia


Just wait until they see the Windows save symbol!


Yeeeaaars ago I remember seeing someone honestly ask "why do you click on a little TV to save a document?"


Apple has icons for SSDs. They are shown in the article right after this:

> So what should Apple do? Customized icons for different types of drives would be a good start. Time Machine drives get custom icons automatically, as do many other types of storage devices that were more common in the past, so surely Apple could design different icons for SSDs and Fusion Drives, and then display them appropriately based on the type of drive.

Apple could repurpose one of the existing SSD icons pretty easily.


> so surely Apple could design different icons for SSDs and Fusion Drives,

That doesn't sound like Apple has icons for SSDs already.


Apple actually does. Like I said, that icon is in the article, right after the paragraph I quoted. Look at the images the author included.

The author is making the point that this shouldn't take much effort because Apple already uses different icons.


Which one of those is supposed to be an SSD icon? Top row we have, from left to right, generic external drive, an optical disk drive, time machine, icloud, shared (network) drive, CD. Bottom row we have three types of floppy disks, a Sony MemoryStick, a CompactFlash, and and SD card.

There's no SSD icon.


Also I don't know why they put a save icon in that list /s


Well, why not? If you're going to be skeuomorphic (which the current icon is), why not be accurate about it?

You can also take it to the extreme and make sure that it's noticebale as an SSD. For example like this: https://dribbble.com/shots/123884-HDRV-Solid-State


Silicon, SSD are transistor-based storage. :P


For the end user a SSD drive is just a black box made of plastic - and that's if they have ever seen it.


On a Mac they are just chips on a board...


An integrated circuit is also "just a black box made of plastic".


You mean "green plate" ?


You think they have seen many HDDs? Especially inside?


Does not matter. Most people have not seen a floppy disk for 15 years at least, but they still understand what it means when they see it ("save as..."). Familiarity.


Exactly !


Yes. It is about as incorrect as the 3.5" Floppy used in Save Icon which most haven't seen one for the past 20 years.

And Child would ask their mum and dad why have they 3D Printed the Save Icon. ( And this is not a Joke )



Nowadays, you could probably make an SSD that looks like an old 3’’ floppy. Might get a bit hot (because of very little airflow and thermal paste) but it could carry plenty of chips/terabytes, in all that space. Add a protected USB-C socket, and at the other end a flexible dock-attachment (like the Nintendo Switch) that looks like an old drive, and you’d have a very retro-looking removable-storage system you can point the kids at.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: