Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

12th or 13th century chivalrous poetry from South of France was still full of feelings and what have you, and a little earlier the Arthur-related stories were not void of feelings either. I personally blame the “Protestant ethic”, for lack of a better name, which started culturally imposing itself starting with the mid-1600s in England and present-day Netherlands (in the early 1600s a guy like Shakespeare was still not afraid to share his feelings in his Sonnets).



Did the majority of 12th century French women consider those poets attractive?


Probably, otherwise why would have they wrote the way that they did? And earlier than that we have Achilles, the male character that is synonymous with courage and presented by Homer as “the greatest of all Greek warriors”, but even so he wasn’t afraid to cry when his close friend Patroclus was killed in battle.


That doesn't show any causality. People write poetry for all sorts of reasons.


Spot on.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: