Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

https://www.absint.com/ is the company that sells licenses/support and they advertise:

> For two decades now, Airbus France has been using our tools in the develop­ment of safety-critical avionics software for sever­al air­plane types, including the flight control soft­ware of the A380, the world’s largest passenger air­craft.

https://www.absint.com/success.htm More customers listed here.



>> Does anyone in the industry use it ? Does anyone knows for sure that Airbus uses it ?

I've heard Xavier Leroy say a year or two ago that Airbus was still evaluating CompCert and was thinking of using it in production for the aircraft generation after the next one, or something like that. And that CompCert sales have been very slow in general.

But here is a paper about an actual industrial user: https://hal.inria.fr/hal-01643290

> https://www.absint.com/success.htm More customers listed here.

AbsInt has been selling timing analysis tools for decades, and Airbus and the other customers are probably almost exclusively customers for those tools. That doesn't mean that those customers also buy CompCert. It seems like they don't.


I have no idea about this specific case, but this kind of claim can be very misleading, while remaining true. Maybe they used the tooling once for an offline script of some sort, and that is all.


It's not misleading in this case. It's used in practice.

You have to understand that CompCert's main competition in this space was an ancient version of GCC without any optimizations. This is mostly an issue of certification. CompCert got the same certification and is already a great improvement just by virtue of having a register allocator...


Good to know, thanks for explaining.

A register allocator! :)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: