Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Bingo!

Excellent point... "Stand-up straight" as advice is simply too simple.

Still, I think your good advice from Trigger Point therapy should be supplemented with some information from the Alexander technique.

You see, original article begin correctly in saying that "bones don't get tired, muscle get tired". If someone could stand or sit without muscular tension, they could avoid getting or aggravating trigger points.

BUT....

It's just that at point of being in distress, people just don't know how to do that. And there really isn't an easy instruction set that will tell most people how to do that because... trigger points and habitual misalignment causes people's sense of their bodily position itself to be distorted. Specifically, when your muscle is habitually shorted, it "feels" to the person like that muscle where it should be. So a person who say is told to "straighten their back" will do by tensing another muscle to fight against their habitually shortened muscle. And so in practice, as you observe, "posture doesn't help".

Still solution to people's misuse of themselves also has include something like a "hands-on retraining" of the body so the muscles and nerve learn together what "upright" actually means.

I'd link to Wikipedia on the Alexander technique but the article has gotten so crufty it's an embarrassment... Still, retraining of "use of the self" is an important compliment to any massage.




I think a lot of the problems are caused by shoes, chairs and toilets. We more fully exercised our range of motion every day before all of these things that made our lives easier and stiffer.


Yes, these things "cause" plenty of problems. But not by themselves - our unconscious adaptation to them is part of the mix as well. The pace of modern life also comes in.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: