Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> And herein is the reason why there are so few female engineers, especially in computer science, laid bare.

Do I read it correctly that "the reason" does not refer to how brains have evolved, but rather to the belief about how the brains have developed? In other words, do you consider the statement about the brains wrong?

If I understand that right, what other related beliefs do you have about brains? That they are exactly the same for men and women, that sexual hormones have zero influence on development and functioning of human brains, that all differences between male and female thinking and behavior are caused by society? Just making sure I am not debating a strawman.

"Tabula rasa" is a popular opinion in certain political circles, but there are two obvious problems with it:

1) It does not explain differences between male and female behavior in animals. Why do e.g. male birds behave differently from female birds; did patriarchy teach them to? A possible answer would be that evolution created mechanisms that apply to all animals, but for some reasons they do not apply to humans. And then humans invented patriarchy, which by sheer coincidence has a similar effect.

2) How about the brain differences where men get it worse? For example, boys being more likely autistic than girls; did patriarchy also do that? Because I am not aware of patriarchy having high opinion about autism; it seems rather the other way round, nerds being stereotypically bullied by jocks; so why would then patriarchy encourage boys to become more autistic?

Note: I agree that society often wildly exaggerates the gender differences, or adds some extra bullshit. I am just saying that this is an exaggeration and distortion of a real thing, not something invented from scratch.

> little girls should be encouraged to become more involved in being system builders and tinkerers, while little boys should be nurtured to develop and show significantly more empathy. This will be hard going, but the good news is that it is entirely doable.

Lest you get too optimistic, going too far in this direction gives us https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Reimer




If I understand that right,

You don’t. Males and females are very, very different because of molecular biology. That is obvious. However, those differences do not make one or the other sex superior or inferior. It also does not mean that females aren’t capable of the same things males are. However, how females think is largely negatively skewed by upgringing. For example, when I see a small girl pushing a toy baby carriage, I see all Red because from experience, that’s brainwashing a little girl that girls are meant to incubate offspring. That’s an opportunity to produce a really good system bilder and thinker, or perhaps a scientist, wasted. Females can be just as good engineers and scientists as males if not better, if only they weren’t being brainwashed during their upbringing. As far as I’m concerned, that’s an intellectual atrocity.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: