Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I’m not really sure why developers of fart apps are automatically off limits or embarrassing.



Really? Is this the best Apple could do?


If Apple blocked fart apps of third-party developers for the sake of... I don't know what, quality or decency, then people would complain Apple are being censors.

Regarding Shoemaker, maybe Apple hired him to direct the App Store because he can run a massive online marketplace, and not because he's a talented or creative app developer.


(A little semantic aside: Apple cannot censor. Governments can, companies cannot. If we broaden the definition of censorship to include companies Apple already censors. Their system is a picture perfect example of censorship, you could use it as an example to explain censorship to school kids – but so are newspapers. This all doesn’t really matter because the word censorship doesn’t have some sort of magic properties. Something can be just as despicable as some activities described by the word censorship even if the usual definition of censorship doesn’t include it. Something can also be a perfectly reasonable activity even if the usual definition of censorship does include it.)


Yes. This is true, but this is now what people are asking. I didn't mean to imply that he wasn't a skilled person in many ways.


If I were responsible for hiring people for that position I would first of all notice that he has experience developing for iOS (but also that his experience doesn’t seem to be huge, he is not at the cutting edge and that he is not very creative) and second of all that because of the type of apps he is developing he might not – culturally speaking – be a good fit for Apple.

A great developer might be wasted at the position Apple were hiring him for but a little experience might be quite good, so the first point could even be positive for him. Whether that second point is true can more or less be sorted out in the interview.

Are you really confident in assessing this person if this is the only thing you know about him? I’m certainly not.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: