Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> So far, in this entire thread, nobody has been able to offer one explanation that doesn't ultimately boil down to either "hospitals don't actually want to increase their profit".

My wife is in med school, here's my argument based on what I see in her education.

Training doctors is fucking hard.

Profits and business and all of that jazz plays a part, sure.

What I've seen is none of that really matters because hospitals can't even get enough qualified staff to support more residency positions. It takes a lot of work for a senior physician to include a medical student or resident in their daily activities. On top of already having a stressful job, dealing with naivety and inexperience of young doctors makes it very unattractive for doctors to want to participate in the process.




> Training doctors is fucking hard. What I've seen is none of that really matters because hospitals can't even get enough qualified staff to support more residency positions.

Yes, and I don't mean to discount the challenges in finding and compensating enough physicians properly for even agreeing to do this in the first place!

Put another way, what I was saying before is that, even if the costs were linear, hospitals couldn't pay for it (without external funding). But as you point out, the costs aren't linear, which makes it even harder.

Or put yet another way, we can't easily increase the number of residents we train to practice medicine, because we don't have enough people trained to practice medicine in order to train them.

This isn't unique to medicine; we have the same problem with law too[0]. Heck, I even know startups that have complained that they don't have the bandwidth they need to hire and train more people.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15758207




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: