Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

JavaScript looks nothing like the “created in 10 days” version to which you speak. I would highly suggest you take an uncomfirmation(?) biased look at the language as it is now. Asyncs simplicity is arguably a reason why it’s a good platform to build off of. I agree I would rather have a single binary, and node may not be the best platform for shells on this point.



> JavaScript looks nothing like the “created in 10 days” version to which you speak.

It has improved, sure. But not only in the direction that makes me happy. But you cannot undo some bad design choices, without it becoming a different language.

> I would highly suggest [...]

I write JS at times. It hurts badly. Not everyone feels it. Maybe coming from PHP or Perl it does not even hurt that much. But after writing some Haskell and Elm lately, the pain got more intense.

> Asyncs simplicity is arguably a reason why it’s a good platform to build off of.

Not having choices is never a good thing in my book. And I do not think that JS does async particularly well. So much line noise when it comes to working with promises.

No fan here.


"Maybe coming from PHP or Perl"

I don't know about PHP (my experience with it is limited), but coming from Perl, Perl is a breath of fresh air in comparison.

Then again, to me Haskell makes even the worst JAPH-style Perl one-liners look readable in comparison, so maybe I'm not the best judge of language design.


i'm with you @cies JS has had some of its edges smoothed out but it's not a great language and its answer to parallelism and concurrency is crap IMNSHO. And i'm someone who came from perl way back in the day.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: