Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> 10.2.2 Layer 1: Integrity (optional)8 > This layer uses a to-be-developed DM target that allows the detection of incorrect data as it is read, by using extra space to record the results of checksum/hash functions on the data blocks, and then compare the results with what the blockdev actually returned. This will enable Stratis to detect data corruption when the pool is non-redundant, and to repair the corruption when the pool is redundant. Such a DM target could use DIF information if present.

This (and other aspects of Strasis) seem like sensible solutions, especially in Linux-land[1]. Implementing this (and I assume dedupe, which is penned for v3 but on which no information is yet provided) at the DM layer means that other FSs can also benefit from this work.

[1] By this I mean that Linux, both as a dev community and as an OS, seems much more comfortable with individual, composable components that can be tied together in different configurations, than monolithic one-size-fits-many solutions like ZFS (and... systemd).




That module is actually already in Linux in the form of dm-integrity: https://github.com/torvalds/linux/blob/master/Documentation/...

I'm using it with mdadm right now and it works pretty okay.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: