Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Did anyone else find the original Amazon Go video's mentioning "deep learning", "webscale technologies" and "generic buzzwords" funny, when in reality they probably use people behind security camera screens tallying up what you buy?



>when in reality they probably use people behind security camera screens tallying up what you buy

I doubt they are using that.


I imagine that edge cases will be flagged and checked by a human operator, a bit like postal services do with machine unreadable addresses. Deep learning isn't perfect - how would you suggest those cases are handled?


>Deep learning isn't perfect

Didn't claim it was.

>how would you suggest those cases are handled?

Obviously the same way as you suggest.

But the parent talked about them MERELY using human operators behind cameras, like it's just some mechanical turk-based fraud...


Eh, I'm sure they use some face recognition to track people and products, but that's about it. How would you have implemented it?


I wouldn't make any claims like Amazon did, unless it was an over 95% automated, with humans involved only in some case of dispute etc.

So, face recognition to track people + image recognition to track products (which is not that difficult, since it's a constrained data set e.g. 40.000 products to train, and they can also use information about position to narrow results -- eg. aisle B, so it's one of the soaps, etc).


"image recognition to track products (which is not that difficult, since it's a constrained data set e.g. 40.000 products to train, and they can also use information about position to narrow results -- eg. aisle B, so it's one of the soaps, etc)."

Wish it was that easy. People have a habit of picking stuff up and putting it in the wrong place. Staff at stores spend forever putting stuff back to it's correct place and binning stuff that should have been refrigerated but placed somewhere non-refrigerated.


>Wish it was that easy. People have a habit of picking stuff up and putting it in the wrong place.

Well, the stuff will already have been identified in the picking stage.


"Well, the stuff will already have been identified in the picking stage."

Sure, but you take some semi-random object out of the basket and add it to the wrong shelf. Do that a few times and things are going to get much harder.

If we're honest, regardless there will be wrong classifications anyway - if it wasn't for laser scanners humans would make more mistakes as well and these are nowhere near human intelligence.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: