Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Say what you like about colonialism, but this kind of shit never happened under the British Empire. They'd come in, kill the local armies and resistance, [...]

In your mind, colonialism[1] has had little to do with the situation we face today? Or its "downsides" are outweighed by whatever good was done?

[1] You know, arbitrary borders against traditional ethnic/cultural separations, slavery, stealing the natives' capital and resources, on one hand stunting the natural evolution of their societies and on the other accelerating it with technology, delaying developing their own good governance over time by installing colonial authorities, etc., etc.




on one hand stunting the natural evolution of their societies

What does that mean? What was pre-colonial Africa evolving towards? And what is your evidence?


> What was pre-colonial Africa evolving towards? And what is your evidence?

It is unknowable. By way of proof of difference I offer the assertion that it is unlikely that a society would be unlikely to arrange itself as a colonial subordinate on its own.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: