Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I'm the author of this piece. can anyone explain why this piece is flagged? it has been submitted, upvoted to the home page, then banned 3 separate times.



I imagine the thinking is that this post might provoke the creation of said "next gawker"


Users of the site, like me, with more than some (nominal, low) amount of karma points clicked the "flag" button that appears under the headline and flagged it off the site.

Your story hasn't been "banned".


what's the difference? It was upvoted to the main page then flagging boots it off right?

and why did you flag it if you don't mind me asking?


It makes an argument I agree with but have read in dozens of other places, and makes it in an insufferable tone. It's written in such a way that it will generate a horrible thread here. Some topics are worth long arguments on HN, but the Nth take on why Thiel vs Gawker is ominous isn't one of them.


ah. just see you edited your comment here. glad you agree w/ the argument.


[flagged]


Are you honestly suggesting you think you might be the first person to write a piece on the implications of billionaires destroying media outlets they disagree with in the wake of the Gawker verdict?

By the way, if you're going to respond to answers to questions you asked with "lol", then yes, I do mind you asking.


did you read the piece? this is a specific implication that I haven't seen elsewhere (you have links?). it's a pretty standard prohibitionist argument and I feel like Hacker News could have a substantive discussion about it. I'm not a journalist, I care about this because I'm also in the tech industry.


A. Yes, I did read the piece.

B. Because you asked me that, this will be the last comment I write about it. Don't ask people whether they've read things they're commenting on.

I think it's a pretty silly piece that starts with an assumption that everyone in tech must side with Thiel and ends with pearl clutching. You asked. Now you know what I think and why I flagged it. I'm just one of many people who did that, and those are just my reasons.

Hope that's helpful.


[flagged]


No, I didn't.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: