Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

For those hatin on speedtest.net and wanting upload, http://speedtest.dslreports.com/ and https://speedof.me/ have booth been around for a while. The reason for fast.com is that it tests download speed from netflix. ISPs can't prioritize it without prioritizing netflix as well.



>ISPs can't prioritize it without prioritizing netflix as well

There are all kinds of tricks they could use to game this. If they applied their throttles over a 5 min window for instance. I'm really curious what Netflix is doing to guard against that, if anything.


Could Netflix start a new TCP connection every 5 minutes?


make a longer test which downloads a video for 10 minutes.


What's the point of the test? Watch a video for 10 or more minutes. Same thing.


Couldn't an ISP prioritize burst traffic but throttle streaming after X minutes?


Yeah, Comcast used to advertise this as "powerboost". http://corporate.comcast.com/comcast-voices/what-is-powerboo... I'm not sure if Xfinity still does that but it wouldn't surprise me.


Powerboost has been dead for a while, but it let your burst above your advertised speed.


They do exactly that. Ever notice how a download/upload is fast for the first few MB then backs off?


That can also be attributed to deep buffering. Your local router and even the next hop will make it look like data is being transferred instantaneously until their buffers fill up.


Download burst on the order of MB/s in the first few seconds can't be attributed to deep buffering. The router doesn't magically have a buffer of things you might visit.


for residential customers traffic shaping in US is very aggressive for majority of ISPs


sounds like we need a test that last as long as a movie.


Perhaps just a (optional) "download speed" display in the corner while watching a movie..


This is built into the Netflix client on most platforms: https://m.reddit.com/r/netflix/comments/2fkylx/hidden_netfli...


Netflix has an unofficial test movie that shows streaming speed: http://www.wired.com/2014/06/netflix-streaming-test/


Or Netflix has a global index on the streaming speed for all movies, per ISP: https://ispspeedindex.netflix.com


But HD is only 5Mbps and 4K is 25Mbps, so you wouldn't necessarily be testing the full bandwidth of your connection.


You could just watch a movie?


I tend to use testmy.net, which includes both upload and download.

> The reason for fast.com is that it tests download speed from netflix. ISPs can't prioritize it without prioritizing netflix as well.

Is there any way to distinguish traffic between the two? Does fast.com actually download a random video from Netflix? Does it benefit from the Netflix local caching server? If ISPs can find a way to cheat, some might.


It downloads over https, so anyone watching the traffic can't really get much more than the domain. The download for me comes from ipv6_1-cxl0-c144.1.sea001.ix.nflxvideo.net which is, i assume, one of the Netflix servers in Seattle over IPv6


Also check out https://broadbandquality.net/ for both a download and upload test.


Netflix should advertise the speeds people are getting from them. And alternative ISPs if things are regularly slow.

Here in the UK we have fibre through one provider and lots through the phone lines because BT were forced to open their network. I get the feeling there is little choice in the US?


Netflix releases a monthly "ISP Speed Index" at https://ispspeedindex.netflix.com.


Be cool if they started putting an ad for the highest Netflix speed in your area at the end of each video though right?


Also: http://beta.speedtest.net (no Flash)


Very very nice ones. dslreports gives bufferbloat. And the n-sized samples of speedof.me are nice.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: