Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

You would rather what a bus?



rather = prefer, here. As in the choice between self driving cars and buses.


I was also confused, and I'm a native speaker. Understanding that "rather" means "prefer" is obvious.

The sentence could be read as "I prefer to be on the road with a bus since I think it's safer". Or it could be "choosing what's most dangerous, I'd rather say it's a bus".

It's also not clear what the perspective of the speaker is. It might be that a bus is safer for the rider, but more dangerous for cars around it. So would he rather be on board a bus, or rather on the road with a bus?


I have no idea how you could get that second interpretation from what he said. And the perspective is clearly inherited from the parent comment, who didn't mention being "on board" a bus, just "on the road with" a bus.

No ambiguity in that comment that I can see.

EDIT: I guess the use of rather in this context could be a colloquialism?


You knew what he/she was trying to say...


Personally, I don't and I'm a native English speaker. I doubt many who weren't would have any chance of deciphering the meaning here either.


I see this usage fairly regularly. I'm not 100% certain of this, but I think it might be more common in Britain than America.


It's just an ellipsis. Or, as my first Google hit said:

"the omission from speech or writing of a word or words that are superfluous or able to be understood from contextual clues."

So: I would rather [have] a bus any day.


Is "I would rather you did..." odd too? Not a native speaker here :)


> Personally, I don't

That's more on you than the OP. It's hardly an unknown phrasing.


Actually, I didn't. It's an odd word choice, and 'prefer' would have made more sense. Rather is typically used in conjunction with another verb, while prefer isn't.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: